The best dog food isn't always the most expensiveWhy it matters
Dog Food Reviews
Brand head-to-head
Black Hawk logo

Black Hawk

0out of 100
Higher overall
vs
Hill's Science Diet logo

Hill's Science Diet

0out of 100

Black Hawk vs Hill's Science Diet

A score-by-score comparison of Black Hawk and Hill's Science Diet — value, ingredients and transparency — run through the same independent 100-point methodology.

By the Dog Food Reviews Editorial Team

Independent scoring · Not pay-to-rank · Last updated June 2026 · Not veterinary advice

Black Hawk tier

Premium

Hill's Science Diet tier

Super-premium

Black Hawk cheapest/kg

$8.45/kg

Lower per kg

Hill's Science Diet cheapest/kg

$11.58/kg

Black Hawk dog food
Black Hawk logo
Higher overall

Black Hawk

EBOS Group (Masterpet, Australia/NZ)

A popular premium-mainstream brand that's everywhere and reasonably priced in big bags — but its strength is reach, not ingredients. Quality swings noticeably across the range: the better formulas lead with named meat, while cheaper lines lean on rice and grain to bulk out the panel. You're partly paying for shelf presence and marketing, so read the specific recipe rather than the brand badge.

PremiumEveryday feeding if you pick the right recipeOwners who want availability over peak ingredients
Read the full Black Hawk review →
Hill's Science Diet dog food
Hill's Science Diet logo

Hill's Science Diet

Hill's Pet Nutrition (Colgate-Palmolive)

A science-led brand with a deep, well-researched prescription range — clinically rigorous and consistent. Outside the therapeutic lines, though, the value is below average for the price: the standard panels lean on corn, grain and by-product meals rather than named single-source protein, and you carry a vet-clinic price premium for the brand and its shelf presence. The prescription range is the reason to buy it, not the everyday food.

Super-premiumVet-prescribed therapeutic dietsGenuine condition-specific feeding
Read the full Hill's Science Diet review →
The scorecard

Score by score

Both brands run through the same six-part model. Higher is better on every dimension — the longer bar marks the leader.

Black Hawk logoBlack Hawk
Hill's Science DietHill's Science Diet logo
76Overall score66
Black Hawk leads
74Price & value52
Black Hawk leads
76Ingredient quality57
Black Hawk leads
76Nutrition77
Hill's Science Diet leads
74Transparency67
Black Hawk leads
83Availability77
Black Hawk leads
76Customer sentiment67
Black Hawk leads
DetailBlack HawkHill's Science Diet
Price tierPremiumSuper-premium
Cheapest per kg$8.45/kg$11.58/kg
Made inAustraliaUSA / Multiple
Who leads where

The verdict, by category

Best value

Black Hawk logo

Black Hawk

Lower cost per day for similar quality.

Best ingredients

Black Hawk logo

Black Hawk

Named-meat-first and protein quality.

Most transparent

Black Hawk logo

Black Hawk

Ingredient, ownership and origin clarity.

76/100
Good
Editorial assessment

Our verdict

On our index, Black Hawk comes out ahead overall (76 vs 66). But the right choice depends on your dog: Black Hawk leads on value, while Black Hawk leads on ingredients. Compare cost per day and the cheapest retailer for each before you buy.

76
Overall
80
vs. avg.
Good
Rating

Not veterinary advice. Good vs Average overall. Prices are illustrative and manually entered for v1 — always confirm live pricing with the retailer.

Other brands worth comparing

Ivory Coat dog food
71/100
Ivory Coat logo
Ivory Coat

Premium · Good

A competent grain-free all-rounder, but it's mid-pack on every measure and now sits inside a big multi-brand portfolio where recipes have moved with ownership. Fine if the price is right on the day — just don't expect it to out-spec a more focused independent brand.

Grain-free everyday feeding where 'good enough' is fine
Compare
SavourLife dog food
75/100
SavourLife logo
SavourLife

Premium · Good

Fair value and the rescue donations are real, not greenwash — but the food itself is good rather than exceptional, with mid-premium panels and a narrow range. Buy it because the per-kg value stacks up, not because the cause makes the ingredients better than they are.

Value-conscious feeders who want a clean enough panel
Compare
Prime100 dog food
78/100
Prime100 logo
Prime100

Premium · Good

A capable single-protein option for elimination diets, and the labels are honest. But the rolls especially carry a steep price per kg for what is a deliberately simple recipe, and the range spread across formats muddies value — price the dry against the rolls per serve before you settle on one.

Sensitive stomachs
Compare

Frequently asked questions

On our value score, Black Hawk edges ahead (74 vs 52). Value is about cost per day, not sticker price — compare the per-kg figures above and the cheapest retailer for each before deciding.

Black Hawk scores higher on ingredient quality (76 vs 57) in our index. We look at named-meat-first, protein source quality, wholefoods and fillers.

Black Hawk scores higher on transparency. Transparency covers ingredient clarity, country of manufacture, ownership and feeding-guide detail.

Online-only retailers like Pet Circle and Budget Pet Products are usually the price-to-beat on everyday pricing, while Petbarn is a strong all-rounder with the widest range, stores nationwide and competitive member and Repeat Delivery pricing. Whichever you choose, compare price per kg before buying.

No. Dog Food Reviews is an independent value and comparison resource, not veterinary advice. Prices are illustrative and manually entered for v1 — always confirm the live price and speak to your vet before changing your dog's diet.

Read the reviews

Find your match

Where to buy