Head to head

Dog food comparisons

Every comparison scores both sides with the same 100-point methodology: value, ingredients, nutrition, transparency, availability and owner sentiment. No pay-to-play, and the same rules for every brand.

Featured

Lyka vs Scratch

Fresh bowls or transparent Aussie kibble? The two subscription favourites, scored.

Read the comparison

Lyka vs Prime100

Fresh subscription vs single-protein rolls for sensitive dogs.

Read the comparison

Lyka vs ZIWI Peak

Gently cooked fresh vs premium air-dried. Two very different premiums.

Read the comparison

Fresh vs kibble

The format question behind every premium switch: what you gain, what you pay.

Read the comparison

All brand comparisons

Black Hawk vs Royal Canin

76 68

Black Hawk vs Hill's Science Diet

76 66

Black Hawk vs Prime100

76 78

Royal Canin vs Hill's Science Diet

68 66

ZIWI Peak vs Prime100

81 78

SavourLife vs Black Hawk

75 76

Scratch vs Petzyo

86 83

Meals for Mutts vs Black Hawk

74 76

Looking for retailer comparisons like Petbarn vs Pet Circle? They live on our parent site: compare online pet food stores at PetReviews.com.au.